ScreenR8 Logo
Movie
Mystery
2h 37m

Zodiac

Released: March 2, 2007
Reviewed: June 5, 2025
Report
Zodiac banner
ScreenR8 Rating
8.5/10
Excellent
Community Rating
76
Very Good

Quick Info

David Fincher's "Zodiac" is one of those films that feels pretty clinical at first, then slowly hooks you with an obsessive chill that creeps up on you. Set in San Francisco amid the Zodiac killings of the late 1960s and 70s, it follows a newspaper cartoonist (Jake Gyllenhaal), a hard-edged reporter (Robert Downey Jr.), and a weary cop (Mark Ruffalo) whose lives spiral as they try to crack the identity of the elusive murderer. This isn’t your typical serial killer movie filled with jump scares or over-the-top confrontations. It’s steady and relentless, much like the case itself.

What stands out most here is the mood. Fincher’s polished direction turns newsrooms and city streets into spaces thick with anxiety. There’s this tint to the cinematography—sort of gloomy and anxious, like the actual fogged-in feeling of not knowing. He’s also incredibly patient, letting scenes hang for just long enough that you start noticing how jittery everyone is. No swelling music cues, no dramatic monologues. Just raw, lived-in tension.

The acting is top-shelf across the board. Gyllenhaal plays the guy who just can’t let it go, slowly unraveling but never tipping into melodrama. Downey Jr. is magnetic as always, bouncing between cocky charm and brittle exhaustion. Ruffalo’s detective is the real backbone—dogged and skeptical, sometimes frustrated to the point of muttering, but never cartoonish. There’s one scene where he simply says “I’m tired of this” in a coffee shop and, honestly, it lands with so much weight that you feel it in your own gut.

If there’s a downside, it’s the pacing. The film is long—like, ‘don’t watch it if you’re sleepy’ long—and it doesn’t care about resolving things quickly because, well, nothing in the real case ever resolved quickly. For some, that’s going to be frustrating. For me, it made the experience feel authentic; the endless red herrings and blind alleys become a kind of punishment for everyone on screen. But you have to be in the right mood for it because this movie is allergic to catharsis.

Not everyone will love the way "Zodiac" eschews easy answers. Instead of righteous closure, you get obsession stretched past the breaking point, and a story more about what the case does to the people than about the killer himself. It’s not always satisfying, but it’s honest.

Still, if you go in expecting a puzzle you’ll never solve, it becomes kind of mesmerizing. "Zodiac" is a rare mix of brainy, chilly, and emotionally bruising. Even if you know all the facts, you’re still left staring at the final frame with a weird sense of unfinished business.

The R8 Take

"

One of the best true crime mysteries ever filmed—if you like "Mindhunter" or "Se7en," you'll find "Zodiac" gets under your skin and lingers long after. It’s a deep dive, but it’s worth it.

"
This part is written by a human